AI and the organisation of workSpain
Información algorítmica
información algorítmica (art. 64.4.d Estatuto de los Trabajadores)
Literally: algorithmic information
- Type
- Law or collective agreement
- Origin
- Real Decreto-ley 9/2021 and Ley 12/2021 (Ley Rider), Estatuto de los Trabajadores art. 64.4.d
- First documented
- 2021
- Spread
- 5 of 6, Studied
- Last reviewed
- 14 November 2026
In short
Since 12 August 2021, article 64.4.d of Spain’s Estatuto de los Trabajadores (Workers’ Statute) gives works councils a right to be told the parameters, rules and instructions behind algorithms or AI systems that shape working conditions, hiring and job retention, profiling included. Spanish sources call it “información algorítmica” (algorithmic information). It applies to every employer, platforms or not (Ministerio de Trabajo, 2022).
Where it comes from

On 25 September 2020, Spain’s Supreme Court ruled in STS 805/2020, its first unifying-doctrine judgment on delivery riders. A social dialogue table opened on 28 October 2020, and on 10 March 2021 Government, CC. OO., UGT, CEOE and CEPYME reached an agreement (Ley 12/2021, preamble).
Real Decreto-ley 9/2021 was signed on 11 May 2021 and published in BOE no. 113 on 12 May 2021. It took effect 3 months after publication (Real Decreto-ley 9/2021). Parliament then passed Ley 12/2021 of 28 September 2021, published on 29 September 2021, which replaced the decree and kept new letter d in article 64.4 (Ley 12/2021). Its preamble says “algorithms deserve our attention and analysis” (“Los algoritmos merecen nuestra atención y análisis”).
Legal scholars call it “Ley Rider” (Ginès i Fabrellas, 2021) or “ley riders” (Pérez Guerrero, 2021), after its focus on platform delivery work. Both authors note that article 64.4.d reaches beyond riders to any company using algorithms.
- 2020Supreme Court ruling STS 805/2020 on delivery riders, 25 September
- 2021Real Decreto-ley 9/2021 adds art. 64.4.d, in force 12 August
- 2021Ley 12/2021 replaces the decree, 28 September
- 2021Just Eat, CCOO and UGT agreement with algorithm clause, 17 December
- 2022Ministry of Labour guide and questionnaire, May
- 2023V AENC sets human control principle for AI, 2023 to 2025
How it works
- Legal wording. Works councils have a right “to be informed by the company of the parameters, rules and instructions on which algorithms or artificial intelligence systems are based that affect decision-making that may impact working conditions, access to and keeping of employment, including profiling” (Ley 12/2021, art. 64.4.d).
- Who must inform. “Todas las empresas que tengan personas asalariadas a su cargo y utilicen algoritmos” (all companies with salaried staff that use algorithms). Collective information applies where staff have legal representatives (Ministerio de Trabajo, 2022).
- What must be disclosed. Ministry guidance groups content in 3 blocks: whether algorithms are used for people decisions and with what degree of human intervention; profiles, variables, parameters, rules, training data and error metrics; and consequences for jobs, gender equality and non-discrimination. Information must be clear to non-technical readers (Ministerio de Trabajo, 2022).
- No source code. The duty “no puede interpretarse como la obligación empresarial de facilitar el código fuente del algoritmo” (cannot be read as an obligation to hand over source code) (Ministerio de Trabajo, 2022).
- Limited duty to negotiate. “Como norma general, no existe la obligación de negociar el algoritmo” (as a general rule, there is no obligation to negotiate the algorithm). Negotiation is due when an algorithm is used in a collective dismissal, and collective agreements can add a duty to negotiate (Ministerio de Trabajo, 2022).
- Questionnaire tool. Ministry guidance ends with a 16-question questionnaire in 4 sections that companies can fill in to meet their information duty (Ministerio de Trabajo, 2022).
- Collective bargaining clauses. Social partners’ V AENC (2023 to 2025) states that AI in companies “deberá seguir el principio de control humano” (must follow the principle of human control) and that companies will give representatives “información transparente y entendible” (transparent and understandable information) on AI used in hiring, evaluation, promotion and dismissal (V AENC, 2023).
Who uses it
Scope is every Spanish employer that uses algorithms in people decisions (Ministerio de Trabajo, 2022).
Takeaway Express Spain (Just Eat) signed a working-conditions agreement with CCOO and UGT on 17 December 2021. Its article 68.e repeats the information right, excludes information protected as intellectual or industrial property, requires “un grado de supervisión humana” (a degree of human supervision) and bars data that could breach fundamental rights, such as sex or nationality. A joint committee, called Comisión Algoritmo, channels the information and hears about substantial changes. Article 68.f says staff must be told whether they are talking to a chatbot, and chatbot conversations cannot be used to sanction anyone (Just Eat, CCOO and UGT, 2021).
Díez Prat and Goux Corredera (Esade DigitalWORK) searched Ministry of Labour REGCON records and found 20 of 4,917 collective agreements, or 0.4%, containing “algoritmo” or “inteligencia artificial”: 14 company agreements, 4 state sector agreements and 2 provincial agreements. They cite an Acciona Mobility clause that refers to article 64.4 (Díez Prat and Goux Corredera, n.d.).
What the evidence says
Peer-reviewed research: legal scholarship describes and assesses the rule. Pérez Guerrero (2021) calls it “una cuestión de suma importancia” (a matter of the highest importance) for preventing discrimination, and stresses its “vocación universal” (universal reach). Baylos Grau (2022) writes that it was “valutata positivamente sia per la sua originalità che per la sua opportunità” (judged positively for its originality and its timeliness). Esteve-Segarra (2022) reports that platform companies have been reluctant to bargain collectively, with Just Eat as an exception. Blasco Jover (2023) examines strengths and weaknesses of the right and calls for legislative reform. No peer-reviewed study measuring effects of article 64.4.d on companies or staff was found for this entry.
Academic commentary: in an IUSLabor editorial, Ginès i Fabrellas (2021) calls the final text “una oportunidad perdida” (a missed opportunity).
Consultancy surveys: no consultancy survey on use of the right was found for this entry. A research report counts 20 agreements with algorithm or AI clauses out of 4,917 reviewed (Díez Prat and Goux Corredera, n.d.).
Administrative or company documents: Ministry of Labour published its guide in May 2022, prepared by an expert committee coordinated by Gemma Galdon Clavell with Anna Ginès i Fabrellas, Ana Belén Muñoz Ruiz, Javier Sánchez Monedero and Adrián Todolí Signes (Ministerio de Trabajo, 2022). Just Eat’s 2021 agreement is the company document that applies the right in detail (Just Eat, CCOO and UGT, 2021).
Spread level 5 of 6
Studied. Described in peer-reviewed research or measured by surveys.
Momentum how it is measured
Gaining ground
Directive (EU) 2024/2831 of 23 October 2024 requires digital labour platforms in every member state to inform platform workers about automated monitoring and decision-making systems, with transposition due by 2 December 2026 (European Parliament and Council, 2024).
Checked 15 November 2026
Limits and criticism
- Lowest level of participation. Baylos Grau (2022) writes that the right “occupa il livello più basso dei diritti di partecipazione” (occupies the lowest level of participation rights), with no consultation process attached, and that “un controllo ‘ex post’ non è sufficiente” (after-the-fact control is not enough).
- No duty to negotiate. Ministry guidance confirms that, as a general rule, companies need not negotiate algorithms with representatives (Ministerio de Trabajo, 2022).
- Collective only, and logic dropped. Ginès i Fabrellas (2021) notes that the right “no puede interpretarse como un derecho individual” (cannot be read as an individual right), that a right to know the algorithm’s logic was left out of the final decree, and that information on outcomes of algorithm use should come with it.
- Trade secrets. Metrics or parameters can be a trade secret (Ginès i Fabrellas, 2021). Pérez Guerrero (2021) reports that some parliamentary groups sought to protect trade secrets, which could narrow the right. Just Eat’s agreement excludes protected information (Just Eat, CCOO and UGT, 2021).
- Vague content and timing. Pérez Guerrero (2021) writes that the law does not say what the information must contain or when it is due. Blasco Jover (2023) argues that legislative reform is needed, with collective bargaining extending powers until then.
- Few representatives where riders work. Esteve-Segarra (2022), citing Sáez Lara, notes that works councils are rare in platform companies, which limits the right’s reach there. Pérez Guerrero (2021) points to dispersed platform workers who find it hard to organise.
- Low uptake in bargaining. Only 0.4% of collective agreements reviewed mention algorithms or AI (Díez Prat and Goux Corredera, n.d.).
What it would take elsewhere
This section is open to members: create your free account to read it, or log in.
The culture this practice needs
Nine cultural conditions decide whether Información algorítmica can take root in an organisation. This profile shows the level each condition needs and which ones are critical.
Part of the Adoption toolkit
The cultural profile of every practice is included in the Adoption toolkit plan, together with Field Notes.
Frameworks. The Leading, Deciding, Evaluating and Disagreeing scales come from Erin Meyer, The Culture Map (PublicAffairs, 2014). The trust, risk-taking and openness elements come from Steve Gruenert and Todd Whitaker, School Culture Rewired (ASCD, 2015). The autonomy and cross-team cooperation conditions are by Benjamin Chaminade. The profile of this practice is an editorial assessment by Trendemic, based on the sources of this entry.
Sources
- Jefatura del Estado (2021). Ley 12/2021, de 28 de septiembre, por la que se modifica el texto refundido de la Ley del Estatuto de los Trabajadores, aprobado por el Real Decreto Legislativo 2/2015, de 23 de octubre, para garantizar los derechos laborales de las personas dedicadas al reparto en el ámbito de plataformas digitales. BOE núm. 233. boe.es
- Jefatura del Estado (2021). Real Decreto-ley 9/2021, de 11 de mayo. BOE núm. 113. boe.es
- Ministerio de Trabajo y Economía Social (2022). Información algorítmica en el ámbito laboral: guía práctica y herramienta sobre la obligación empresarial de información sobre el uso de algoritmos en el ámbito laboral. mites.gob.es
- Dirección General de Trabajo (2023). Resolución de 19 de mayo de 2023, por la que se registra y publica el V Acuerdo para el Empleo y la Negociación Colectiva. BOE núm. 129. boe.es
- Takeaway Express Spain (Just Eat), FSC-CCOO and FeSMC-UGT (2021). Acta de acuerdo, expediente SIMA-FSP M/441/2021/N, acuerdo de condiciones de trabajo. ccoo-servicios.es
- Pérez Guerrero, M. L. (2021). La “ley riders”: ¿problema o solución? Trabajo, Persona, Derecho, Mercado, 4, 189 to 196. doi.org
- Baylos Grau, A. (2022). L’accidentato viaggio dei riders in Spagna. Analisi della legge n. 12/2021. Labour & Law Issues, 8(1). doi.org
- Esteve-Segarra, A. (2022). Riders de empresas de plataforma ¿Cuál es vuestro convenio colectivo? Lan Harremanak, 48, 141 to 164. doi.org
- Blasco Jover, C. (2023). El derecho de información algorítmica de los representantes de los trabajadores. Trabajo y Derecho, 105. observatorio-cientifico.ua.es
- Ginès i Fabrellas, A. (2021). El derecho a conocer el algoritmo: una oportunidad perdida de la “Ley Rider”. IUSLabor, 2/2021 (editorial). raco.cat
- Díez Prat, F. and Goux Corredera, H. (n.d.). DigitalWORK: estudio de la negociación colectiva en IA y digitalización. Esade. esade.edu
- European Parliament and Council (2024). Directive (EU) 2024/2831 on improving working conditions in platform work, Articles 9 and 29. eur-lex.europa.eu
